West Virginia Court of Claims January 18, 2011, CC-09-0202 (Evans v. Division of Corrections)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-01-2011

PER CURIAM:

Claimant, an inmate at Mount Olive Correctional Complex, a facility of the Respondent, brought this claim to recover the value of personal property that he alleges was negligently destroyed by Respondent. Claimant placed a value of $355.00 on his personal property.

A hearing was conducted by the Court in this claim on October 21, 2010, at which time the Claimant testified as to the facts and circumstances giving rise to the claim. Mr. Evans was living in a double cell with another inmate in Oak Hall until January 14, 2009, when he was disciplined and sent to Paugh Hall, designated “Loss of Privileges pod” or “LOP,” for thirty (30) days. On the date of his transfer, Mr. Evans was instructed to pack his appliances for storage in a closet in LOP while he was in lock-up. Mr. Evans stated that he packed his 13-inch Sharp flat panel TV and remote in a five-gallon plastic trash bin and placed it in the corner of the storage closet to protect the screen during storage. Claimant testified that he had watched his TV the day of transfer and it was in fine working order when he left it in storage. According to Mr. Evans, from his cell in LOP he could observe people entering and exiting the storage closet. Upon being released from LOP, Claimant reclaimed his TV, which he alleged had been moved. Mr. Evans stated that when he returned to his cell and plugged in his TV he noticed the LCD panel was damaged and notified Unit Manager William Kincaid.

Claimant submitted into evidence Operational Procedure # 4.03, which provides Respondent’s policies regarding inmate property and State Shop procedures. West Virginia Division of Corrections Operational Procedure No. 4.03, Inmate Property & State Shop Procedures (June 1, 2009). According to the operational procedure, when an inmate is moved from his cell, “all property located within the cell will be searched, inventoried and stored within the State Shop Property Room.” Id. § V(E)(7)(d).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.