District Court, M.D. Alabama November 3, 2011, Civil Action No. 1:11-CV-461-WHA (M.D.P. v. Houston County Health Care Authority)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-11-2011

MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER

W. HAROLD ALBRITTON, Senior District Judge.

I. INTRODUCTION

This case is before the court on a pair of Motions to Dismiss filed by Guy Malcolm Middleton, M.D. (“Middleton”) and Dothan OBGYN, Inc. (“OBGYN”) jointly (Doc. # 10), and by Houston County Health Care Authority d/b/a Southeast Alabama Medical Center (“SAMC”) and Dawn Michelle Ralls (“Ralls”) jointly (Doc. # 11), on August 26, 2011. The court has diversity of citizenship jurisdiction over this action.

The Plaintiffs, M.D.P., Gavin J. Pugh, and Abby Nicole Pugh, collectively (“the Plaintiffs”), filed a Complaint in this court on June 14, 2011, alleging three claims. Count I alleges that Defendants Middleton, OBGYN, and SAMC breached a contract of which Plaintiffs were third party beneficiaries, and Count II alleges that all the Defendants committed medical negligence by breaching the applicable standards of care for medical professionals concerning the birth of M.D.P. Also, in a separate claim, not numbered as a Count but labeled Derivative Claims of Gavin and Abby Pugh, Plaintiffs Gavin and Abby Pugh also allege individual claims for emotional distress and mental anguish as the result of the Defendant’s aforementioned breach of contract and medical malpractice claims as to M.D.P.

SAMC and Ralls filed a Motion to Dismiss raising two issues: (1) that Count I, breach of contract, is preempted by Count II, tort, and should be dismissed as a separate claim, and (2) that the Derivative Claims of Gavin and Abby Pugh, fail as a matter of law because there was no physical injury to those Plaintiffs, and also because they are barred by the statute of limitations.

Middleton and OBGYN filed an Answer which included a Motion to Dismiss, asserting failure to state a claim and failure of the Complaint to specify the date in year 2004 when Plaintiff M.D.P. was born. The Answer included a defense of the statute of limitations.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.