Idaho Supreme Court September 6, 2011, 35117 (State v. Flegel)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-09-2011

combined-opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF IDAHO

Docket No. 35117

STATE OF IDAHO, )

) Boise, May 2011 Term

Plaintiff-Respondent, )

) 2011 Opinion No. 94

v. )

) Filed: September 6, 2011

CHRISTOPHER DAVID FLEGEL, )

) Stephen W. Kenyon, Clerk

Defendant-Appellant. )

)

Appeal from the District Court of the Fourth Judicial District of the State of

Idaho, in and for Ada County. The Hon. Michael E. Wetherell, District Judge.

The judgment of the district court is vacated.

Sara Thomas, Deputy State Appellate Public Defender, Boise, argued for appellant.

Jessica Lorello, Deputy Attorney General, Boise, argued for respondent.

EISMANN, Justice.

This is an appeal from a conviction for the crime of sexual abuse of a child under sixteen

years of age charged in an amended indictment. Because that crime had not been submitted to

the grand jury and was not an included offense of the crime of lewd conduct charged in the

original indictment, the district court did not have subject matter jurisdiction. We therefore

vacate the judgment and remand this case with instructions to dismiss the case without prejudice.

I.

Factual Background

Flegel was indicted by a grand jury for the crime of lewd conduct with a child under

sixteen years of age (Lewd Conduct) in violation of Idaho Code section 18-1508. Flegel pled not

guilty and was tried by a jury. The district court instructed the jury regarding the crime of Lewd

Conduct and, as an included offense, the crime of sexual abuse of a child under sixteen years of

age (Sexual Abuse). The Lewd Conduct charge was based upon the allegation that Flegel

touched the child’s vagina, and the Sexual Abuse charge was based upon evidence that he also

touched her buttocks. The jury found Flegel not guilty of Lewd Conduct, but could not reach a

verdict on the Sexual Abuse charge.

Without resubmitting the matter to a grand jury, the State filed an amended indictment

charging Flegel with the crime of Sexual Abuse.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.