Montana Supreme Court May 3, 2011, OP 11-0206 (Office of the State Public Defender v. Montana Eighteenth Judicial District Court)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-05-2011

No. OP 11-0206 May 3 2011

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF MONTANA

2011 MT 97

______________

THE OFFICE OF THE STATE PUBLIC DEFENDER, )

)

Petitioner, )

)

v. )

) ORDER

MONTANA EIGHTEENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT ) and

COURT, GALLATIN COUNTY, THE ) OPINION

HONORABLE HOLLY BROWN, District Judge, and )

THE HONORABLE MIKE SALVAGNI, District Judge, )

)

Respondents. )

______________

¶1 The Office of the State Public Defender (OPD) has filed a petition for writ of

supervisory control in which it asks us to vacate an order appointing OPD to represent

petitioner Matthew Ulrigg in Gallatin County Cause No. DV 11-342A unless the District

Court complies with § 46-21-201, MCA. OPD also asks us to prohibit the District Court

from appointing OPD in any postconviction proceeding until after the court has received a

response to the petition from the State of Montana. OPD has attached to its petition copies

of orders in which both Judge Holly Brown and Judge Mike Salvagni have taken the position

that §§ 46-21-201(2) and 47-1-104(4)(a)(v), MCA, allow a district court to appoint OPD in a

postconviction proceeding upon the court’s determination that the interests of justice require

such appointment, even if that determination is made before a responsive pleading is filed.

¶2 Supervisory control is an extraordinary remedy that is sometimes justified when

urgency or emergency factors exist making the normal appeal process inadequate, the case

involves purely legal questions, and, among other alternatives, the other court is proceeding

under a mistake of law and is causing a gross injustice. See M. R. App. P. 14(3). As to the

issue presented here, OPD has no right of appeal, and the issue is a pure legal issue of

statutory interpretation. Moreover, we conclude, as described more fully below, that the

District Court is proceeding under a mistake of law causing a gross injustice. For those

reasons, we have determined to exercise our power of supervisory control.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.