Colville Confederated Court of Appeals November 28, 2011, Nos. AP11-011, AP11-009 (Desautel v. Colville Confederated Tribes)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-11-2011
DUPRIS, C.J.
SUMMARY
Defendant/Appellant Olney (Olney) was charged by criminal complaint on December 14, 2010. On the same day she was appointed services of the Public Defender’s Office. The Order Appointing Public Defender included imposition of a $75.00 attorney fee. Olney went to trial on March 15, 2011. After the Prosecution’s case in chief, Olney moved for a directed verdict. The motion was granted and an Order Dismissing the case entered, with the provision that the case would not be dismissed until the $75 fee was paid. Olney timely filed a Notice of Appeal, citing several issues. This opinion will only discuss and decide the issue of attorney fees. The other issues will be decided in a separate order.
Defendant/Appellant Desautel (Desau-tel) was charged by criminal complaint on December 27, 2010. That same day, the Public Defender’s Office was appointed to represent Desautel. The Order Appointing Public Defender included imposition of a $200.00 attorney fee. Appellant went to trial, was found not guilty by a jury, and an Order Dismissing Case was entered on
*208April 5, 2011. The Order included a provision that the case would not be dismissed until the $200.00 was paid by the Defendant/Appellant. Defendant/Appellant timely appealed.
Based on the reasoning below, we reverse the imposition of attorney fees and remand.
STANDARD OF REVIEW
The issue before this Court is a question of law, therefore we will review de novo, Simmons v. CCT, 6 CCAR 30, 3 CTCR 45, 29 ILR 6065, — Am. Tribal Law - (2002); Palmer v. Millard, et al., 3 CCAR 26, 2 CTCR 14, (1996); Naff v. CCT, 2 CCAR 50, 2 CTCR 8, 22 ILR 6031 (1995).
ISSUE 1
Does the Trial Court have authority to collect attorney fees before entering a not guilty verdict?
DISCUSSION
Appellants in both of these cases argue that the requirement of attorney fees being paid before a case will be dismissed is a violation of due process. Desautel was found not guilty by a jury at trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit