Superior Court of Guam August 2, 2012, CM0609-11 (People v. Sotelo & Saunders)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-08-2012

combined-opinion

IN THE SUPERIOR COURT

OF GUAM

2

3

PEOPLE OF GUAM, ) Criminal Case No. CM609-11

4 )

)

5 v. )

ORDER

)

6

AUGUST C. SOTELO and BRIAN )

7 SAUNDERS, )

)

8 Defendants.

9

10 After reviewing the instant case, the Court sua sponte DISMISSES the case against both

11

Defendants because neither ofthem was promptly arraigned.

12

Under Guam law, a "defendant shall be arraigned promptly after the indictment or

13

information is filed or after the complaint is filed where prosecution by complaint is required

14

15 by § 1.15." 8 GCA § 60.1O(a). Furthermore, the Supreme Court of Guam held, "unless good

16 cause is shown, a complaint shall be dismissed where a defendant is not promptly arraigned

17

within sixty (60) days of the filing of the complaint." People v. Rasauo, 2011 Guam 14 ~ 14

18

("Rasauo 11"). The Court also held this "standard continues to require a case by case analysis

19

of whether or not the 'specific circumstances' of any given case shows good cause for delay

20

21 beyond the 60 day period normally required to comply with the law." Id.

22 Here, the complaint was filed May 16,2011, and a summons was issued directing only

23

Defendant Saunders to appear on July 20,2011. The Court notes, however, by July 20, 2011, it

24

was already five (5) days past the 60-day limit. The Court also notes that Defendant Sotelo was

25

26

never summoned. Because the 60-day speedy arraignment deadline set by the Supreme Court

27 of Guam was violated, both Defendants not being arraigned within the 60-day limit, this case

28 must be dismissed. Rasauo, 2011 Guam 14.

Page 1 of2

The Court finds that dismissal should be with prejudice. The Supreme Court of Guam

2

applied the statutory speedy trial time period in Rasauo II. This is significant because when a

3

Defendant's right to a speedy trial is violated the action against that Defendant is dismissed

4

with prejudice. It is not unreasonable to apply the same rule in the instant case.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.