Superior Court of Guam January 10, 2012, CV0187-06 (Pangelinan v. Dept. of Corrections)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-01-2012

combined-opinion

,

~rr;tor~ IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF GUAM

FfLE

law librarl

3 20l? JAN 10 PM q:oo

)

4

FRANK E. PANGELINAN, )

5 )

Plaintiff, )

6 ) DECISION AND ORDER

v. ) ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR

7

) APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL

8 DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS, AS AN)

INSTRUMENTALITY OF THE )

9 GOVERNMENT OF GUAM, )

)

to

Defendant. )

II

----------------------------)

12 INTRODUcrION

13

This matter came before the Honorable Alberto C. Lamorena, III, on the plaintiff

14

motion for appOintment of counsel. Assistant Attorney General William C. Bischo

IS

represented the Department of Corrections. Plaintiff appeared pro se. After consideratio

16

of the parties' arguments the Court now issues its Decision and Order.

17

FAcrUAL HISTORY

18

Plaintiff is an inmate at the Guam Department of Corrections ("DOC"). Plaintiff fil

19

a complaint on February 23, 2006 initiating this action alleging negligence by DOC i

20

overseeing and protecting inmates. Currently, the plaintiff is apparently classified as

21

"maximum custody'" inmate and because of this classification, the plaintiff is not allowe

22

physical access to DOC's law library to conduct research. Moreover, plaintiff alleges tha

23

DOC does not provide legal assistance to inmates from persons trained in the law. Due t

24

plaintiffs limited knowledge of the law and his lack of access to legal research materials

25

plaintiff filed the present motion requesting that this Court appoint counsel to assi

26

plaintiff in prosecuting his civil action.

27

28

J.

DISCUSSION

2

The issue presented here is whether an indigent prisoner who has successfully file

3

a civil claim, but lacks physical access to a law library should be appointed counsel to assis

4

in the prosecution of the civil action? This Court finds that Guam law does not grant th

5

trial court authority to appoint counsel to assist a prisoner under these circumstances.

6

Guam Miscellaneous Rule 1.1.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.