District Court, D. New Hampshire December 20, 2012, 12-CV-411-SM (D’Angelo v. NH Supreme Court, et al.)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-2012

D’Angelo v . NH Supreme Court, et a l . 12-CV-411-SM 12/20/12

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

Stephen L . D’Angelo,

Plaintiff

v. Case N o . 12-cv-411-SM

Opinion N o . 2012 DNH 204

New Hampshire Supreme Court, and

Brian Germain, Esq.,

Defendants

O R D E R

The plaintiff, Stephen D’Angelo, appears pro se (although he

is an attorney). He brings this action seeking compensatory,

declaratory, and injunctive relief, asserting that the state

courts violated his Fifth and Fourteenth Amendment rights during

the course of child support proceedings to which he was a party.

The Magistrate Judge has reviewed the complaint in due course and

has filed a formal Report and Recommendation, in which she

recommends dismissal of all D’Angelo’s claims for lack of subject

matter jurisdiction, after applying the Rooker-Feldman doctrine.

Defendants also move to dismiss all of plaintiff’s claims.

Plaintiff objects.

The Report and Recommendation is adopted in part,

defendants’ motions to dismiss are granted, and all of

plaintiff’s claims are dismissed.

Background

D’Angelo has been involved in an ongoing dispute over his

child support obligations since approximately 2006. The New

Hampshire Circuit Court, 10th Circuit, Family Division (the

“Derry Family Court”) conducted a number of hearings and issued

several orders in an effort to resolve D’Angelo’s financial

obligations to his son. In those various orders, the court

observed that, D’Angelo “has a well-documented history of

thwarting the discovery process and of selectively excluding

relevant financial information to the detriment of the

Petitioner,” Complaint, Exhibit H (document n o . 1 - 8 ) , Order dated

May 1 5 , 2012 (“DFC Order”) at 1 (quoting a prior order). It also

noted that it had “already found M r . D’Angelo in Contempt of

Court on multiple occasions.” Id. at 3 . The court went on to

observe that D’Angelo (a practicing attorney):

would represent that his gross income ranges from

$29,500 to a high of $93,387.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.