Indiana Court of Appeals October 17, 2012, 53A04-1202-PL-95 (Earl F. Shields, Larry J. Shields, and Robert L. Shields v. Rodney L. Taylor)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-10-2012

FOR PUBLICATION

FILED

Oct 17 2012, 8:47 am

CLERK

of the supreme court,

court of appeals and

tax court

ATTORNEY FOR APPELLANTS: ATTORNEY FOR APPELLEE:

MICHAEL O. ELLIS MICHAEL L. CARMIN

Bloomington, Indiana Andrews, Harrell, Mann, Carmin &

Parker, P.C.

Bloomington, Indiana

IN THE

COURT OF APPEALS OF INDIANA

EARL F. SHIELDS, LARRY J. SHIELDS, )

and ROBERT L. SHIELDS, )

)

Appellants, )

)

vs. ) No. 53A04-1202-PL-95

)

RODNEY L. TAYLOR, )

)

Appellee. )

APPEAL FROM THE MONROE CIRCUIT COURT

The Honorable Douglas R. Bridges, Senior Judge

Cause No. 53C06-1104-PL-589

October 17, 2012

OPINION - FOR PUBLICATION

BROWN, Judge

Earl Shields, Larry Joe Shields, and Robert Shields (collectively, the “Shields”)

appeal the trial court’s Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Order, and subsequent

denial of the Shields’ motion to correct errors, in favor of Rodney Taylor. The Shields

raise one issue which we revise and restate as whether the court erred in concluding that

their counterclaim was not sufficiently pled to encompass a theory of easement by

prescription. We affirm.

FACTS

The relevant facts follow. The Shields and Taylor are owners of adjacent parcels

of land in Monroe County, in which Taylor’s parcel is situated to the north of the Shields

parcel. Taylor’s property is bordered on the north side by Earl Young Road. Taylor

purchased his property approximately fifteen years ago from John and Phyllis Chuke,

who had previously purchased the property from Frank Hudoff. The Shields have owned

their property for three generations. The Shields’ property is divided into two parts by a

steep hill, and they have driven across Taylor’s property on a dirt road accessed from Earl

Young Road in order to reach the back portion, which they called “the long bottom,” for

the last forty or fifty years. Transcript at 166. In the time that Taylor had owned his

property, the Shields had not spoken with Taylor about their using it to access the long

bottom and felt they had no reason to do so.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.