United States Bankruptcy Appellate Panel for the Ninth Circuit April 6, 2012, NC-11-1173-DoDH (In re: JOSEPH J. VIOLA AKA GIUSEPPE VIOLA)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-04-2012

FILED

APR 06 2012

1

ORDERED PUBLISHED SUSAN M SPRAUL, CLERK

U.S. BKCY. APP. PANEL

2 O F TH E N IN TH C IR C U IT

3 UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY APPELLATE PANEL

4 OF THE NINTH CIRCUIT

5

6 In re: ) BAP No. NC-11-1173-DoDH

)

7 JOSEPH J. VIOLA aka ) Bk. No. 10-30904

GIUSEPPE VIOLA, )

8 ) Adv. No. 10-03103

Debtor. )

9 )

)

10 JANINA M. HOSKINS, )

Chapter 7 Trustee, )

11 )

Appellant, )

12 v. ) O P I N I O N

)

13 CITIGROUP, INC.; CITIGROUP )

GLOBAL MARKETS, INC.; )

14 CITIBANK, N.A., )

)

Appellees. )

15 ______________________________)

16

17 Argued and Submitted on January 20, 2012

at San Francisco, California

18

Filed - April 6, 2012

19

Appeal from the United States Bankruptcy Court

20 for the Northern District of California

21 Hon. Dennis Montali, Bankruptcy Judge, Presiding.

22

23 Appearances: John H. MacConaghy of MacConaghy & Barnier argued

for the appellant. Stefan Perovich of Keesal,

24 Young & Logan argued for the appellees.

25 Before: DONOVAN,1 DUNN, and HOLLOWELL, Bankruptcy Judges.

26

27

1

Hon. Thomas B. Donovan, United States Bankruptcy Judge for

28 the Central District of California, sitting by designation.

1 DONOVAN, Bankruptcy Judge:

2

3 Janina M. Hoskins (Hoskins), chapter 7 trustee for the

4 estate of Joseph Viola (Viola), appeals an order of the

5 bankruptcy court dismissing with prejudice Hoskins’ Second

6 Amended Complaint against Citigroup, Inc. (Citigroup), Citigroup

7 Global Markets, Inc. (CGMI), and Citibank, N.A. (Citibank),

8 (collectively Citi), for avoidance of fraudulent transfers and

9 damages for aiding and abetting intentionally fraudulent

10 transfers. We AFFIRM the dismissal.

11 I. FACTS

12 Viola, a convicted felon and fugitive from justice,

13 approached a San Francisco branch of Citibank managed by vice

14 president Rik B. Schrammel on or about April 14, 1999.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.