Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York December 20, 2012 (Richmond Medical Center v. Daines)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-2012

McCarthy, J.

For the reasons stated in Matter of Bronx-Lebanon Hosp. Ctr. v Dairies (101 AD3d 1431 [2012] [decided herewith]), Supreme Court did not err in looking beyond the petition itself and considering respondents’ submissions. Similar to that case, the issue comes down to when petitioner received DOH’s determination letter, as that is the date from which the four-month statute of limitations began to run (see New York State Assn, of Counties v Axelrod, 78 NY2d 158, 165 [1991]). Respondents bear the burden of establishing their statute of limitations defense (see Matter of Feldman v New York State Teachers' Retirement Sys., 14 AD3d 769, 770 [2005]). Because they did not meet that burden as a matter of law, and questions of fact exist, Supreme Court should have held a trial on that narrow issue.

In support of their motion, respondents submitted the affidavit of a DOH employee whose duties include preparing notifications for mailing. She averred that the June 24, 2010 letter was sent to petitioner via certified mail, the green card was returned to DOH signed but not dated, and the article number for the letter was checked through the United States Postal Service (hereinafter USPS), which indicated that the letter was received *1436on June 30, 2010.2 A copy of the returned green card shows that it was signed, but the printed name of the recipient and the date of delivery are not listed (although the card has lines for that information). The USPS track and confirm report, printed from the USPS website, lists the status as “[delivered” and states that “Your item was delivered at 1:57 pm on June 30, 2010 in STATEN ISLAND, NY 10310.”

In response, petitioner submitted the affidavit of its messenger, who averred that the USPS does not deliver mail to petitioner. Rather, the messenger picks up the mail at the local post office twice each day. On his first mail run, he gets only bulk mail before the clerk’s window is open.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.