Court of Appeals of Maryland May 23, 2012, No. 114 (Cordish Power Plant Ltd. Partnership v. Supervisor of Assessments)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-05-2012
lead-opinion
BATTAGLIA, J.
We are called upon to determine whether a ground lease1 owned by the City of Baltimore must be considered in the *3valuation of an “income producing commercial real property”2 to which it is attached (for purposes of real property tax valuation), regardless of whether the lease itself has been proven to be restrictive of the use of the property.
Cordish Power Plant Limited Partnership and Cordish Power Plant Number Two, LLC (collectively “Cordish”), Appellants, lease from the City two adjoining pieces of real estate on East Pratt Street in Baltimore City known as the Power Plant Building and the Pier IV Office Building. After the two properties were valued by the Supervisor of Assessments for Baltimore City, Appellee, together at $38,138,600 for real property tax purposes, Cordish challenged the valuations in separate cases before the Property Tax Assessment Appeals Board, which affirmed, and thereafter before the Maryland Tax Court.
In both cases before the Tax Court, Cordish introduced appraisals and testimony that valued the properties at $29,900,000 collectively, based in part on the existence of ground leases owned by the City of Baltimore; the leases, themselves, however, were not introduced into evidence during the proceedings. The Supervisor of Assessments for Baltimore City, Appellee, argued that consideration of the ground leases was contrary to Section 8-113 of the Tax-Property Article, Maryland Code (1985, 2007 RepLVol.),3 which requires, *4as a general rule, that interests subject to property tax under Section 6-102 of that Article be valued as though the lessee were the owner. The Tax Court affirmed the $38,138,600 valuation for the two properties collectively,4 which was subsequently affirmed upon judicial review by the Circuit Court for Baltimore City.
Cordish appealed and, prior to any proceedings in the Court of Special Appeals, we granted certiorari, 424 Md. 628, 37 A.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit