Michigan Court of Appeals November 6, 2012, Docket No. 230858 (Adair v. Michigan)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-11-2012

ON THIRD REMAND

Before: SAAD, EJ., and TALBOT and FORT HOOD, JJ.

TALBOT, J.

This original action returns on remand from our Supreme Court for a determination of costs to be awarded to plaintiffs under § 32 of the Headlee Amendment, Const 1963, art 9, § 32.1 We referred this matter to a special master, with the consent of the parties, to review the reasonableness of plaintiffs’ claim for costs, including attorney fees, and to conduct fact-finding. We have reviewed the report of the special master, the objections of the parties to that report, and the meager evidentiary record. We decline to award plaintiffs any attorney fees. Plaintiffs have failed to *389carry their burden of proving the number of hours reasonably expended in litigating their recordkeeping claim during phases I and II of these proceedings. Moreover, plaintiffs are not entitled to attorney fees for phase III of these proceedings, as a matter of law, because the ratifiers of the Headlee Amendment did not intend § 32 to authorize an award for attorney fees incurred in postjudgment proceedings. With regard to the other costs incurred in the maintenance of this suit, we find the special master’s construction of the term “costs” to be overly restrictive in light of Macomb Co Taxpayers Ass’n v L Arise Creuse Pub Sch, 455 Mich 1; 564 NW2d 457 (1997). This narrow view of what constitutes an awardable cost under § 32 impedes our ability to assess costs in a fair and informed manner and, therefore, we are compelled to return this matter to the special master for the taking of additional proofs and for a recalculation of the costs to be awarded in accordance with this opinion.

COSTS AWARDABLE PURSUANT TO CONST 1963, ART 9, § 32

I. REASONABLE ATTORNEY FEES

Const 1963, art 9, § 32 governs the costs to be awarded to a taxpayer who sustains an action to enforce the provisions of the Headlee Amendment.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.