Massachusetts Superior Court August 29, 2012, No. WOCV201002623B (Marzilli v. UMass Memorial Medical Center, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-08-2012
Tucker, Richard T, J.
This came before the Court upon motions for summary judgment under Rule 56, Mass.R.Civ.P. The defendants UMass Memorial Medical Center, Inc. and Delta Beckwith Elevator, Co. assert that no genuine issues of material fact exist, and they are entitled to judgment as a matter of law. Upon consideration of the arguments of the parties, the motion record and the authorities relied upon the motions for summary judgment are ALLOWED.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The motion record reveals that on May 1, 2008 the plaintiff fell and was injured as she was entering lobby elevator “B” at the Hahneman campus, UMass Memorial Medical Center, Worcester, Massachusetts (UMass). In her fall, her shoulder was dislocated. Upon discovery by hospital personnel, she was taken to the emergency room where she was treated. After a period of rest, diagnostic testing and observation the plaintiff underwent arthoscopic shoulder surgery in early June 2012 to repair a torn rotator cuff. Following said surgery she performed physical therapy.
The plaintiff was employed at the time of her fall in a law office. Upon learning of plaintiffs injury, later on the day of the injury, lawyers from her firm went to the site. They observed and took photographs of the elevator at which plaintiff fell. The lawyers observed a discrepancy between the elevator floor and the lobby floor of “a little over one quarter inch,” which one attorney has described in an affidavit. No warnings were reported as being posted at the elevator.
The service contract between the defendant UMass and the defendant, Delta Beckwith Elevator Co. (Delta) requires that the elevators be maintained to level with the outside floor with no more than a one-quarter to one-half inch discrepancy.
Plaintiff claims that the defendant UMass was negligent in its maintenance of its property and in failing to warn foreseeable users of the elevator of its defective condition.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit