District Court, W.D. Washington September 27, 2012, Case No. C10-1010RAJ (Read v. Moe)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-09-2012

ORDER

RICHARD A. JONES, District Judge.

I. INTRODUCTION

This matter comes before the court on two motions to dismiss from Defendant Frekhaug Stal AS, as well as Plaintiffs two motions to compel discovery related to the motions to dismiss. Dkt. ##45, 47, 51, 68. Although the parties requested oral argument, oral argument is unnecessary in light of the court’s disposition today. For the reasons stated below, the court DENIES Frekhaug Stal’s motions to dismiss (Dkt. ## 45, 47) and GRANTS Plaintiffs motions to compel (Dkt. ## 51, 68). This order concludes with instructions for the parties to complete discovery on personal jurisdiction and to submit additional briefing. The court directs the clerk to create a motion calendar for November 16, 2012, to address the parties’ new submissions.

II. BACKGROUND

In August 2007, a “snap hook” 1 aboard the commercial fishing vessel F/V TONGASS LADY broke, causing the portion still attached to a line to swing free and strike Plaintiff C.B. in the face, severely injuring her. At the time, the TONGASS LADY was in navigable waters off the coast of Alaska. Plaintiff was a minor.

Plaintiff, through her guardian ad litem, filed this suit in June 2010. She named as Defendants Greg Moe, who is the owner of the TONGASS LADY, the vessel itself, and Frekhaug Stal, the Norwegian company who manufactured the snap hook. She invoked the court’s admiralty jurisdiction, asserting no claims under the law of any state. Not long thereafter, Mr. Moe filed an answer and a cross-claim against Frekhaug Stal and a separate exoneration of liability action (In re Moe, No. 10-1287RAJ), which was also assigned to this court. In August 2010, the court stayed this case in light of the exoneration of liability action. No. 10-1287RAJ (Dkt. # 4). Frekhaug Stal was not a party in the exoneration action. Perhaps unaware of the stay, Frekhaug Stal filed a September 2010 motion in this case to extend its deadline for responding to Plaintiffs complaint.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.