District Court, D. New Jersey September 27, 2012, Civil No. 09-2119 (NLH)(KMW) (Granger v. Acme Abstract Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-09-2012
OPINION
HILLMAN, District Judge.
This matter has come before the Court on defendants’ motion for summary judgment on plaintiffs claims that defendants violated plaintiffs copyrighted title insurance calculators when they posted the calculators on their website. For the reasons expressed below, defendants’ motion will be granted.
BACKGROUND
Plaintiff, John Granger, claims that in 2002 he created the “Pennsylvania Title Insurance Calculator” and the “New Jersey Insurance Calculator” for use on the internet, and he registered these works with the U.S. Copyright Office on October 2, 2006. In his complaint, plaintiff contends that in October 2003, defendants Acme Abstract Company and Acme Ab*421stract, LLC,1 their managing member, defendant Robert J. Lohr II, and their website designer, defendant Ralph Shicatano, infringed on his copyrights when his title insurance calculators were placed on their website, which advertised their title insurance business. In May 2006, plaintiff sent defendants a letter in May 2006 informing them that it had come to his attention that his copyrighted title insurance calculators appeared on their website, and he requested that defendants provide him with a written licensing agreement allowing them to do so. “Silence beyond two weeks shall serve as proof that no written licensing agreement exists” between plaintiff and defendants. (Def. Ex. 1, May 2, 2006, Letter from John Granger to Acme defendants.)
Lohr attempted to contact plaintiff by telephone and email, but plaintiff never responded back. Defendants removed both calculators from the website by May 8, 2006. After not hearing again from plaintiff for several years, on May 1, 2009, plaintiff served defendants with his instant complaint, claiming copyright infringement and other violations, including tortious interference with prospective economic advantage, fraudulent business practices, and unfair competition. Defendants have moved for summary judgment in their favor on all claims.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit