District Court, E.D. Louisiana September 28, 2012, Civil Action Nos. 08-4007, 08-4156, 08-4023, 08-4046, 08-4261, 08-4600 (Gabarick v. Laurin Maritime (America), Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 28-09-2012
OPINION
IVAN L.R. LEMELLE, District Judge.
This litigation involves complicated fact pattens and interwoven legal issues. It begins with a series of vessel chartering agreements by American Commercial Lines, Inc. (“ACL”) and D.R.D. Towing Company, LLC (“DRD”) — an arrangement described by ACL as a “two step, two contract process”. Record Document Number 1381, p. 55. The pertinent arrangement involves charter for the M/V MEL OLIVER (“MEL OLIVER”). In another vein, we are presented with numerous contracting and operational arrangements involving Whitefin Shipping Co., Ltd., Laurin Maritime AB, Laurin Maritime (America) Inc., Anglo-Atlantic Steamship Limited, and the M/V TINTOMARA (“TINTOMARA” interests). Record Document Number 1383, pp. 38-43. The collision between the ACL owned barge DM-932, under tow by the MEL OLIVER, with the M/V TINTOMARA resulted in the sinking of that fuel oil laden barge, damages to the TINTOMARA, and various other claims between aforementioned parties, the tugs crew and third parties. Prior to this vessel limitations trial, collateral federal criminal proceedings were filed against the tug operator and owner/managers of the tug, which resulted in convictions by guilty pleas from those parties. Administrative proceedings were also held pursuant to Coast Guard and Oil Pollution Act regulations.
In its two-step with DRD, ACL contracted its tug PAM D, later substituted with the MEL OLIVER, to DRD for a specified time period. DRD paid a charter rate for the vessel of $1.00 per day provided the vessel was, in the second step, simultaneously chartered back to ACL by DRD to work exclusively in ACL’s service at a higher daily or market based rate. Jim Masters, T.Tr. Vol. IX (AM), pp. 32-37, D. Dantin T.Tr. Vol. VI (AM), p. 103; Exhs. 700-702, inclusive. Because of a shortage of licensed personnel to operate its tugs and to achieve economics savings, ACL contracted with DRD to operate ACL owned tugs — including the PAM D and the substituted MEL OLIVER.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit