District Court, N.D. Indiana October 18, 2012, Case No. 3:11-CV-0302 (Jones v. Alpha Rae Personnel, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-10-2012

OPINION AND ORDER

PHILIP P. SIMON, Chief Judge.

Plaintiff Christina Jones brought this action against her employer, defendant Alpha Rae Personnel, and Alpha Rae’s contractor, defendant Affiliated Computer Services, asserting retaliation claims under Title VII. Jones alleges that Alpha Rae and ACS removed her from ACS’s South Bend job site in retaliation for filing two formal concurrent complaints with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and the South Bend Human Rights Commission claiming race-based discriminatory conduct by her supervisor and other ACS employees. Jones also brought a defamation claim, but she appears to have abandoned it. Alpha Rae and ACS now seek summary judgment.

The main problem for Jones is that it’s pretty clear from the record that she wasn’t a model employee — far from it, in fact. ACS cited Jones for numerous deficiencies before Jones filed her first discrimination complaint. And her inadequate performance continued after her complaints were filed, which led to her termination. Jones’s only response to this evidence is that the timing of her removal is suspicious. But that’s not enough, for two reasons. First, she mistakes the event that must be the predicate for any suspicious timing argument — the protected activity that is the basis for the retaliation claim, which in this case occurred many months before her removal. And even setting that aside, Seventh Circuit precedent is clear that suspicious timing alone is generally insufficient to prove a retaliation claim. That principle is particularly applicable where, as here, an overwhelming weight of evidence shows that the adverse *682action was undertaken for reasons apart from any retaliatory motive.

I therefore must conclude that the evidence in this case — when viewed in the light most favorable to Jones — shows that her prior discrimination complaints did not play a substantial role in Alpha Rae’s and ACS’s decision to remove her from the ACS job site.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.