District Court, D. Utah October 17, 2012, Case No. 2:07-MC-630 (Archuleta v. Turley)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-10-2012
TENA CAMPBELL, District Judge.
On June 1, 2012, Petitioner Michael Anthony Archuleta filed what was incorrectly styled as an Objection to Appearance of Mark Field as Counsel for Respondent and a Memorandum in Support of Petitioner’s Objection to Appearance of Mark Field as Counsel for Respondent.1 {See Dkt. No. 41 and 42.) After the court granted an extension of time to submit his response, Respondent Steven Turley2 filed his Response on July 3, 2012. {See Dkt. No. 47.) Mr. Archuleta submitted his Reply on July 17, 2012. {See Dkt. No. 49.)
Mr. Archuleta argues that because Mr. Field handled his state habeas appeal as a law clerk when the case was in the state court system, Rule 1.12 of the Utah Rules of Professional Conduct bars Mr. Field from now representing the state in Mr. Archuleta’s federal habeas action before the court. Rule 1.12 prohibits former judges and law clerks from later representing anyone in connection with “a matter” on which they “personally and substantially” worked. See Utah R. Profl Conduct 1.12(a). Mr. Archuleta contends that he will suffer prejudice in his habeas proceedings before the court unless Mr. Field is disqualified because Mr. Field’s violation of Rule 1.12 results in an unfair advantage for the state.
The state does not dispute that Mr. Field worked as a law clerk for state district court judges with capital cases, or that Mr. Field was “personally and substantially” involved in Mr. Archuleta’s habeas appeal when it was in state court. The state also agrees that the Utah Attorney General assigned Mr. Field to work on federal capital cases, including Mr. Archuleta’s.
But the state takes the position that because Mr. Archuleta’s state habeas appeal is not the same matter as his federal habeas appeal, Rule 1.12 does not prohibit Mr. ■ Field from working on the federal habeas case. The state also argues that even if Rule 1.12 prohibits Mr. Field’s involvement in Mr.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit