District Court, D. Arizona December 21, 2012, Nos. 2:12-cv-01227 JWS, 4:12-cv-00661 JWS (IDS Property Casualty Insurance v. Gambrell)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-12-2012

ORDER AND OPINION

JOHN W. SEDWICK, District Judge.

I. MOTIONS PRESENTED

Defendant Stacey Harrish (“Harrish”) filed a motion 'to dismiss pursuant to Rule 12(b)(6) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure at docket 5 in Tucson Case No. 4:12-cv-00661 (“Tucson Case”), which Harrish and Defendant IDS Property Casualty Insurance Company (“IDS”; collectively “Defendants”) removed from Pima County Superior Court. In the motion to dismiss, Harrish argues that she was an improperly named party against whom no cause of action can lie.

About two weeks after Harrish filed her motion to dismiss, plaintiffs Frank and Bettina Gambrell (“Gambrells” or “plaintiffs”) 1 filed a motion at docket 7 to remand the Tucson Case back to Pima County Superior Court pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1447(c), arguing that there is not complete diversity because Harrish is a resident of Arizona. Defendants filed an opposition at docket 11 in the Tucson Case. While they acknowledge that Harrish is a resident of Arizona, they assert that she *750was “fraudulently joined” to the case while it was in state court, meaning they believe plaintiffs have no valid cause of action against Harrish, and thus, her inclusion was designed to block federal diversity jurisdiction.

The Gambrells asked the court to stay the briefing on Harrish’s motion to dismiss until the court resolved the jurisdictional issues in the motion to remand,2 but the court denied the request, opting to consider the motions together, given the similarity of the issue at stake in both motions— 1.e., whether a claim of bad faith against Harrish exists under Arizona law.3

The court consolidated the Tucson Case with Phoenix case 2:12-cv-01227 (“Lead Case”), which is IDS’s related declaratory judgment action against the Gambrells. After consolidation, the Gambrells subsequently filed their opposition to Harrish’s motion to dismiss at docket 22 in the Lead Case and filed their reply to the motion to remand at docket 20.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.