District Court, D. Arizona May 11, 2012, No. CV 12-117-TUC-RCC (Pfeiffer v. Morgan Stanley Credit Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-05-2012

ORDER

RANER C. COLLINS, District Judge.

When Plaintiff bought his home, he paid no money down and financed the purchase through a promissory note made out to Morgan Stanley Credit Corporation (MSCC) secured by a deed of trust for the home and funds in his brokerage account. (Doc. 1-4). Plaintiff now seeks a declaration that Arizona’s anti-deficiency laws prevent Defendants from holding his brokerage account as collateral. For the reasons discussed below, the Court finds that Arizona’s anti-deficiency laws do not prevent this arrangement and that summary judgment in favor of Defendants is appropriate at this time.

I. Background

A. Procedural Summary

Plaintiff originally filed this action in Pima County Superior Court seeking declaratory and injunctive relief as to his rights to access a brokerage account pledged as security for promissory note. (Doc. 1-4). After Defendants removed the case, the Court set a hearing on Plaintiffs application for a temporary restraining order. (Docs. 10-11). At oral argument, the parties requested the Court treat the mat*830ter as a motion for summary judgment. (Doc. 22). The Court declined to convert the application because further development of the record was necessary. (Doc. 18). Later, the Court requested additional briefing from the parties, which has now been completed. (Docs. 19, 23-26).

B. Factual Summary

In July 2005, Plaintiff bought his home for $330,000.1 (Complaint at ¶ 12). Plaintiff paid no money down and financed the purchase through a promissory note made out to MSCC secured by a deed of trust for the home and funds in his brokerage account. (Id. at 15 and 19-26).

The agreement relative to the brokerage account is laid out in two contracts: the Pledge and Security Agreement (PSA) and the Account Control Agreement (ACA). (Id. at ¶ 19).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.