New Mexico Court of Appeals January 17, 2012, No. 33,353; Docket No. 29,933 (Flemma v. Halliburton Energy Services, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-01-2012

lead-opinion

OPINION

SUTIN, Judge.

{1} Edward R. Flemma, an employee of Defendant Halliburton Energy Services, Inc. (Halliburton), was terminated allegedly for voicing opposition to a proposed location for a new Halliburton facility, and he sued Halliburton and three of its employees claiming wrongful and retaliatory discharge. Defendants appeal the district court’s refusal to compel arbitration. We reverse, holding that (1) under Texas law there was sufficient evidence of Flemma’s acceptance of and assent to a contractual arbitration program when Halliburton mailed the terms to Flemma, and Flemma accepted the terms by continuing employment with Halliburton; (2) the differences between Texas and New Mexico in terms of the evidence required to prove acceptance and assent are insufficient to overcome application of the place-of-contract-formation rule on public policy grounds and, thus the arbitration agreement should be enforced under Texas law, which was the state where the contract was formed; and (3) under Texas law the arbitration agreement was not illusory and was therefore supported by consideration.

BACKGROUND

{2} Flemma was hired by Halliburton in 1982 in Louisiana. During his twenty-six years of employment with Halliburton, Flemma received numerous promotions, including his latest promotion, in 2006, to district manager for the company in Farmington, New Mexico. Flemma was involved in evaluating the move of three Halliburton facilities from established locations in Farmington to a more suitable, consolidated location. Halliburton considered two locations for the consolidated facility — Troy King, within Farmington’s city limits, and Crouch Mesa, outside the city limits. For various reasons, Flemma opposed the Troy King location.

{3} The facts surrounding Flemma’s termination are undisputed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.