Massachusetts District Court, Appellate Division May 23, 2012 (Killoran v. Boyles)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-05-2012

Brennan, PJ.

The plaintiff, Frank J. Killoran (“Killoran”), commenced this tort action on July 6, 2010 to recover for injuries allegedly sustained in an automobile accident on January 29,2004. After filing their answer, the defendants moved to dismiss the complaint as barred by the statute of limitations and not within the saving provisions of G.L.c. 260, §32. The dismissal motion was allowed, and Killoran has appealed.

1. Although the defendants referenced Mass. R. Civ. R, Rule 12(b)(5), 12(b)(6), 12(b) (9), and 12(b) (10), the substance of both their motion and supporting memorandum identified their request as one for dismissal under Rule 12(b)(6). See Lambley v. Kameny, 43 Mass. App. Ct. 277, 280 (1997) (“[T]he label attached to a... motion is far less important than its substance.”); Babco Indus., Inc. v. New England Merchants Nat'l Bank, 6 Mass. App. Ct. 929 (1978) (“A motion to dismiss under Mass. R. Civ. E, Rule 12(b)(6),... lies against a complaint which shows on its face that the statute of limitations has run prior to the date the action was commenced.”). An initial procedural problem neither addressed nor argued by either party is that the defendants’ Rule 12(b) (6) motion was untimely because it was submitted after the filing of their answer. Mass. R. Civ. R, Rule 12(b) (noting that'Rule 12(b)(6) defense “shall be made before pleading if a further pleading is permitted”).

The solution to this procedural problem is that the defendants’ dismissal motion could have been properly treated by the trial court as one pursuant to Rule 12(c). A defendant retains the right to raise the defense of failure to state a claim after the pleadings are closed, and may do so by filing a Rule 12(c) motion for judgment on the pleadings. Mass. R. Civ. R, Rule 12(h)(2).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.