Massachusetts District Court, Appellate Division May 24, 2012 (Bernard v. First Nation Construction Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-05-2012
MacLeod, J.
This is an action by homeowners to recover damages for breach of contract by a construction corporation and its individual officers.
The record indicates that in December, 2004, Richard and Susan Bernard (“Bernards”) contracted with First Nation Construction Corporation (“First Nation”) for demolition work and for the construction of a single-family house and garage. First Nation assured the Bernards that it employed an expert finishing carpenter, and referred them to several places where it had completed projects. The Bernards visited those sites and were satisfied with the completed work. At the time they contracted with the Bernards, the sole shareholders and officers of First Nation were David A. Vandale (‘Vandale”), a fifteen-year licensed general contractor supervisor, and James Labillois (“Labillois”), a three-year licensed home improvement contractor.
In May, 2005, after work had commenced on the Bernards’ project, Vandale withdrew from the corporation because he was dissatisfied with both Labillois’ hiring decisions and the framing crew’s substandard work. Pursuant to a stock and asset purchase agreement dated May 2, 2005, Vandale withdrew corporate assets in exchange for transferring his interest in the corporation to Labillois. Labillois agreed *90(1) to “postpone any insolvency proceedings” for First Nation until Vandale had been paid; and (2) along with First Nation, to indemnify Vandale from claims arising before or after the date of the agreement.
Following Vandale’s departure, the Bernards became dissatisfied with the defective construction work by First Nation and the shoddy plastering done by Labillois’ wholly owned business, J&S Plastering Construction (“J&S”). Project problems included a defective wall, frozen and delaminating plaster, incomplete electrical functions, and gaps around doors and windows. Both First Nation and J&S abandoned the project in early 2006 pursuant to a cease work order by Labillois.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit