Court of Appeals of Washington September 16, 2013, 68528-7 (Carolina Becerra Becerra v. Expert Janitorial)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-09-2013

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

CAROLINA BECERRA BECERRA; No. 68528-7-1

JULIO CESAR MARTINEZ MARTINEZ;

MOISES SANTOS GONZALEZ; DIVISION ONE

HERIBERTO VENTURA SATURNINO;

ORLANDO VENTURA REYES; JOSE

LUIS CORONADO; ALMA A.

BECERRA; and ADELENE MENDOZA

SOLORIO,

Appellants,

v.

EXPERT JANITORIAL, LLC, dba PUBLISHED

EXPERT JMS; and FRED MEYER

STORES, INC., FILED: September 16. 2013

Respondents,

CZ5

—ic:

ALL JANITORIAL, LLC; SERGEY CO

oo

n '

CHABAN; ALL AMERICAN m

JANITORIAL, LLC; RAUL CAMPOS;

cr.

and JANITORIAL MAINTENANCE &

wrr

SUPPLY, LLC, dba JMS,

Defendants. CD — -

Cox, J. — The primary issue in this case of first impression is whether

either Fred Meyer Stores, Inc. or Expert Janitorial, LLC is a "joint employer" of

the appellant janitors under Washington's Minimum Wage Act (MWA). We hold

that the proper test to determine this legal question is the "economic reality" test.

That test requires examination of all factors relevant to the particular employment

No. 68528-7-1/2

situation to determine the economic reality ofthe relationship.1 We also hold that

there are genuine issues of material fact regarding the existence and degree of

some of the relevant factors used to determine the economic reality of the

plaintiff janitors' relationship with Fred Meyer and Expert, respectively.

Accordingly, we reverse the summary judgment orders granting dismissal and

remand for further proceedings.

In 2004, Fred Meyer, a large retail company with stores in Washington

and other areas of the Pacific Northwest, began to outsource janitorial work that

had previously been done by employees of the company. Several years later,

the Puget Sound area Fred Meyer contracted with Janitorial Management

Services (JMS), a company that later merged with Expert Janitorial, to provide

janitorial services.

In the contract between Fred Meyer and Expert, Fred Meyer included a

detailed outline of the cleaning tasks to be completed by the janitors working in

1 See Rutherford Food Corp. v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.