Superior Court of Guam March 15, 2013, DM0860-11 (Medina v. Munoz)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-2013

combined-opinion

2

3

4 IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF GUAM

5

PETER RAFFEY MEDINA, )

6 CASE NO. DM0860-11

)

7 Plaintiff, )

)

8 )

V.

9 ) DECISION AND ORDER

LOLITA MUNOZ, BUENVENIDO P. )

10 BARCINAS, and KENNIDIE I.M. )

BARCINAS, )

II

)

12 Defendants. )

13

14 INTRODUCTION

15 This matter came before the Honorable Alberto C. Lamorena III on December

16 17, 2012 on Defendants' Motion to Dismiss. Plaintiff Peter Medina was represented

17

by Attorney Seaton M. Woodley, III. Attorney William Pesch represented

Defendants Lolita Munoz, Buenvenido P. Barcinas and Kennidie I.M. Barcinas.

18

Following the hearing the Court took the matter under advisement. Having

19

considered the parties' arguments and the applicable law, this Court now issues its

20

Decision and Order.

21

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

22

Plaintiff Medina filed a suit to establish paternity of Kennidie Barcinas

23

(hereinafter, "Kennidie"). On August 9, 2012, this Court dismissed the action for

24

failure to serve necessary parties. An amended complaint was then filed and served

25

upon Kennidie and Buenvenido Barcinas ("Buenvenido"), who was married to Lolita

26

Munoz ("Lolita") when Kennidie was born. Buenvenido and Lolita, since divorced,

27

continue to have joint legal custody over Kennidie.

28

Decision and Order

Case No. DM0860-ll

Plaintiff :Medina has moved for genetic testing to establish paternity

2 pursuant to 5 G.C.A. § 34119. Plaintiff contends he, not Buenvenido, is Kennidie's

3 father. Defendants collectively challenge Medina's standing as to his ability to

4 challenge Buenvenido's presumed paternity as well as his ability to move for genetic

5 testing and have filed a motion for Summary Judgment.

6

DISCUSSION

7

Defendants have moved for summary judgment pursuant to Guam R. Civ. P.

8

56(b). In considering a motion for summary judgment, this Court "must draw

9

inferences and view the evidence in a light most favorable to the non-moving party."

IO

Bank of Guam v. Flores, 2004 Guam 25 ~ 7.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.