Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas December 11, 2013, PD-0209-12 (Johnson, Jackie)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-12-2013

IN THE COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

OF TEXAS

NO. PD-0209-12

JACKIE JOHNSON, Appellant

v.

THE STATE OF TEXAS

ON APPELLANT’S PETITION FOR DISCRETIONARY REVIEW

FROM THE FOURTEENTH COURT OF APPEALS

HARRIS COUNTY

P RICE, J., filed a concurring opinion in which W OMACK, J., joined.

CONCURRING OPINION

I join the Court’s opinion today, but I write separately to clarify one point. The Court

correctly acknowledges that, in reviewing a motion to suppress, an appellate court should

review a mixed question of law and fact de novo unless it happens to turn on witness

credibility or demeanor.1 The Court then declares that the court of appeals erred in failing

1

Majority Opinion at 12 (citing State v. Kerwick, 393 S.W.3d 270, 273 (Tex. Crim. App.

2013)).

Johnson — 2

to conduct a de novo review in this case—but without explaining why the mixed question of

law and fact did not turn on witness credibility or demeanor.2 Given that there was some

dispute in the testimony at the motion to suppress hearing, some explanation is in order.

Whether an interaction between police and a citizen constitutes a mere encounter or

a detention is, I agree with the Court today, a mixed question of law and fact.3 Whether that

mixed question of law and fact should be considered deferentially or de novo by a reviewing

court depends upon whether that mixed question turns on a dispute of historical fact or

credibility of the witnesses.4 A reviewing court must defer to a trial judge’s determination

of historical facts, and make the legal determination whether a particular interaction is an

encounter or a detention by applying the law to those accepted historical facts.5 Likewise,

when resolution of the legal issue turns on a material conflict in the testimony of the

witnesses, a reviewing court must defer to a trial judge’s determination with respect to which

witness or witnesses, or what aspect of their testimonies, to believe or otherwise credit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.