Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit May 6, 2013, 11-90099 (In Re Complaint of Judicial Misconduct)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-05-2013

FOR PUBLICATION

JUDICIAL COUNCIL

OF THE NINTH CIRCUIT

IN RE COMPLAINT OF No. 11-90099

JUDICIAL MISCONDUCT ORDER

Filed May 6, 2013

ORDER

KOZINSKI, Chief Judge:

Complainant, a pro se litigant who suffers from a

communications disability, alleges that a district judge

discriminated against him by refusing to allow complainant’s

caretaker to act as his “authorized representative” and

“address the court in his behalf.” In asking that his caretaker

be allowed to represent him, rather than simply transmit his

statements to the court, complainant sought more than a

“reasonable accommodation” for his disability. He requested

that the caretaker provide a service that may be performed

only by a licensed attorney, which his caretaker was not. See

28 U.S.C. § 1654. The district judge’s denial of such a

request was entirely proper.

In any event, complainant was never required to speak in

court without assistance: The district judge ruled that

complainant’s case could be decided on the pleadings and

removed it from the motion calendar. Even when all parties

2 IN RE COMPLAINT OF JUDICIAL MISCONDUCT

are represented by counsel, this is not uncommon, if the judge

believes that resolution of the case would not be aided by oral

argument. The Court of Appeals affirmed the district judge,

also without oral argument, which confirms that the district

judge was reasonable in deciding the case on the pleadings

alone.

Complainant also alleges that the district judge refused

his accommodation request as retaliation for the fact that

complainant filed a motion to recuse. In a supplemental

filing, he further alleges that the judge tried to obstruct this

misconduct complaint by dismissing his underlying civil case

on the merits. As we have frequently held, adverse rulings,

standing alone, are not proof of misconduct. See In re

Complaint of Judicial Misconduct, 583 F.3d 598, 598

(9th Cir. 2009). Because complainant offers no other support

for these allegations, these charges must be dismissed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.