Texas Court of Appeals, 12th District (Tyler) December 20, 2013, 12-12-00425-CR (State v. Terence Johnson)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-2013

NO. 12-12-00425-CR

IN THE COURT OF APPEALS

TWELFTH COURT OF APPEALS DISTRICT

TYLER, TEXAS

THE STATE OF TEXAS, § APPEAL FROM THE

APPELLANT

V. § COUNTY COURT AT LAW

TERENCE JOHNSON,

APPELLEE § HOUSTON COUNTY, TEXAS

OPINION

The State appeals the trial court‟s order granting Appellee Terence Johnson‟s motion to

dismiss. The State raises two issues on appeal relating to the constitutionality of Texas Penal

Code Section 42.11. We affirm.

BACKGROUND

Appellee Terence Johnson was charged by complaint and information with the offense of

destruction of a flag, committed on or about April 29, 2012. Appellee filed a motion to dismiss

on the grounds that Section 42.11 of the penal code (the Texas flag destruction statute) is

unconstitutional and its enforcement interferes with his right to free speech. The State argued

that Appellee‟s conduct was not speech and that the statute is constitutional.

The trial court disagreed with the State‟s contention that Appellee‟s act of pulling a local

business establishment‟s flag off its post and throwing it into the street did not constitute speech.

The court reasoned that if the act of burning the flag is protected speech, then so too is the act of

throwing a flag to the ground. Stating that it was bound by the holdings in United States v.

Eichman, Texas v. Johnson, and State v. Jimenez, the trial court dismissed the case.1 This

appeal followed.

CHALLENGING CONSTITUTIONALITY

The trial court dismissed the State‟s information against Appellee, finding “that Section

42.11 is unconstitutional and [its] enforcement . . . unconstitutionally interferes with [Appellee‟s]

right of free speech.” When the constitutionality of a statute is challenged on appeal, we review

the trial court‟s ruling de novo. See Lawson v. State, 283 S.W.3d 438, 440 (Tex. App.—Fort

Worth 2009, pet. ref‟d). We presume a statute is valid and that the legislature did not act

unreasonably or arbitrarily in enacting the statute. Battles v. State, 45 S.W.3d 694, 702 (Tex.

App.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.