Texas Court of Appeals, 5th District (Dallas) July 24, 2013, 05-12-00292-CV (Rodney R. Elkins & Co. v. Uno Immanivong)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-07-2013

Reverse and Remand; Opinion Filed July 24, 2013.

In The

Court of Appeals

Fifth District of Texas at Dallas

No. 05-12-00292-CV

RODNEY R. ELKINS & CO., Appellant

V.

UNO IMMANIVONG, Appellee

On Appeal from the County Court at Law No. 3

Dallas County, Texas

Trial Court Cause No. CC-11-5262-C

OPINION

Before Justices Lang, Myers, and Evans

Opinion by Justice Evans

This is an appeal from a county court order dismissing Rodney R. Elkins & Co.’s lawsuit

against Uno Immanivong for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. Appellant contends the county

court, sitting in its appellate capacity, had jurisdiction over the case because the amount in

controversy did not exceed $10,000 when the action was filed in the justice of the peace court.

Appellant also complains he was denied the opportunity to be heard on the motion to dismiss

before it was granted by the court. We conclude that the county court erred in dismissing the

suit because the amount of damages specifically pleaded in the justice court were within its

jurisdictional limits and there was no evidence the allegations were fraudulently made to confer

jurisdiction. Accordingly, we reverse the dismissal order and remand the cause to the county

court for further proceedings consistent with this opinion.

Appellant sued appellee in justice court to recover $8,416.26 in unpaid legal fees,

interest, and necessary attorney’s fees in an unspecified amount. The justice court granted

appellant’s motion for summary judgment and rendered a final judgment in its favor for

$13,550.27. Appellee appealed the judgment to the county court. Appellee then filed a motion

in county court to dismiss the suit for lack of jurisdiction arguing that when appellant filed its

original petition in justice court, it was clear the amount of attorney’s fees would be over

$1,583.74 and, thus, the amount in controversy exceeded the justice court’s $10,000

jurisdictional limit.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.