Court of Appeals of Washington January 8, 2013, No. 29749-7-III (State v. Andrews)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-01-2013
Brown, J.
¶1 — Jamie Andrews appeals his witness tampering conviction. He contends insufficient evidence *705supports his conviction and the trial court erred in admitting copies of text and voice message evidence. We affirm.
FACTS
¶2 Carrie Frazier was subpoenaed as a witness in Ron Ralston’s motor vehicle theft trial but did not show up; she was scared to testify against Mr. Ralston at trial. After officers arrested Ms. Frazier on a material witness warrant, they obtained a search warrant for her cellular phone. Using a digital camera, Officer Michael Durbin photographed text messages he found on Ms. Frazier’s cell phone and used a digital recorder to record voice messages. The State charged Mr. Andrews with intimidating a witness or, alternatively, witness tampering. At trial, over Mr. Andrews’ objection, Ms. Frazier testified to three voice messages left on her cellular phone.
¶3 On the first message, the caller, identified as ‘Yoshie,” told Ms. Frazier, ‘You need to fucking stay under the radar. Stay the fuck down and yeah just be like that girl. Now that’s on, that, that is on the real because if it happens any different than yeah, you’re gonna have some problems.” Ex. 12; Report of Proceedings (RP) at 1. Ms. Frazier understood the message to mean that she was to make herself unavailable to testify at trial, that Yoshie was serious, and that she might be subject to retaliation if she did show up to testify. The second message, again from Yoshie, demanded a call back from Ms. Frazier in order to make sure “you’re doing what you’re supposed to do.” Ex. 12; RP at 1. Ms. Frazier understood that he was checking to make sure she was not going to trial. In the third voice message, Yoshie instructed Ms. Frazier to let him know “where you are and what’s up” and “I think it’s today.” Ex. 12; RP at 2. Ms. Frazier understood that Yoshie was requesting that she should stay unavailable for just one more day, and the trial would be over with.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit