Court of Appeals of Washington September 12, 2013, No. 29645-8-III (State v. Ruiz)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-09-2013
Korsmo, C.J.
¶1 Five men were murdered in a Pasco garage in 1987 by two gunmen. One of the gunmen pleaded guilty and testified under oath at his plea hearing about how he and his cousin, appellant Vicente Ruiz,1 committed the massacre. When Mr. Ruiz was apprehended and tried in 2010, his cousin refused to answer when questioned by the prosecutor consistent with his previous testimony. Thé primary contention in this appeal is whether the prosecutor erred in questioning the recalcitrant witness despite his refusal to answer. We conclude that this was permissible and affirm the convictions for five counts of aggravated2 first degree murder and one count of attempted first degree murder.
*628FACTS
¶2 The sole survivor of the shootings was Aldo MontesLlamas,3 who was working with the other five men inside Medina’s Body Shop on the evening of October 13, 1987. About 6:45 p.m., he saw two men arrive in a Mazda RX-7. The two men had contact outside the building with two mechanics; the mechanics then departed and the two men entered the shop. One of them was holding a .357 handgun in one hand and what appeared to be a .38 pistol in the other. The second man carried a chrome Mini-14 rifle. They rounded up the body shop workers and started shooting.
¶3 Mr. Montes-Llama dived under a car; a ricocheting bullet struck him in the abdomen. When the shooting ended, the two men went to their car and left; Mr. MontesLlama drove himself to a police station and reported the shootings. An ambulance took him to the hospital while law enforcement descended on the body shop.
¶4 Detective Henry Montelongo spoke to Montes-Llama at the hospital. He told the detective that the men were “Calentones” and mentioned the name “Vicente.” The detective knew the Calentones as a branch of the Mendez family in Pasco. Meanwhile, the body shop owner, Clifford Medina, named Vicente Mendez (Ruiz) as a possible suspect and told them Mendez was associated with a blue Camaro.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit