District Court of Appeal of Florida February 27, 2013, No. 2D11-5549 (Oldham v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-02-2013

KELLY, Judge.

Huey Oldham appeals from his judgment and sentence for possession of a controlled substance and possession of drug paraphernalia. He filed a motion to suppress evidence that the trial court denied. He then entered a no contest plea to the charges, reserving his right to appeal the denial of his dispositive motion to suppress. Because we agree that the search *964conducted by police exceeded the scope of Mr. Oldham’s consent, we reverse.

Hillsborough County sheriffs deputies went to' Mr. Oldham’s residence to investigate a neighbor’s complaint that Mr. Old-ham was manufacturing methamphetamine on his property. As deputies approached the residence, they made contact with Mr. Oldham who was walking away from a smoldering fibre pit on the north side of the residence. One of the deputies explained they were there to investigate a complaint that he was manufacturing methamphetamine on his property, and they asked him what he was burning. Mr. Oldham stated that he was stripping and burning copper wire and scrap metal. One of the deputies asked Mr. Oldham if he could “look around” the fire pit area to verify that he was burning copper wire, not manufacturing methamphetamine. Mr. Oldham agreed.

The deputy testified that the area around the fire pit was littered with piles of “all sorts of stuff’ including copper wire, electronics, cinder blocks, and batteries. As the deputy looked around the fire pit, he saw a small “pill-style” plastic case on top of a pile of cinder blocks or electronics. A portion of a plastic baggie was sticking out of the container. The deputy opened the container and observed a white powdery substance which tested positive for methamphetamine. As he did in the trial court, Mr. Oldham contends that the officer’s search of the closed plastic container exceeded the scope of his consent to search the fire pit area. We agree.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.