Louisiana Court of Appeal September 13, 2013, No. 2012 CA 2121 (Gibbs v. Elliott)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-09-2013

McClendon, j.

|2In this defamation suit, the plaintiff appeals the judgment of the trial court, dismissing her suit with prejudice pursuant to a' special motion to strike. For the reasons that follow, we affirm.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

As background, this dispute arose out of litigation in Pointe Coupee Parish between clients of the defendant, Neal R. Elliott, Jr., a Baton Rouge attorney, and Herbert R. Witty, the father of the plaintiff, Dana Witty Gibbs. Mr. Elliott represented several legatees in an action against Mr. Witty in the 18th Judicial District, Court for his actions as executor of the succession of Nita Marie LeBeau. The trial court ultimately found Mr. Witty liable for breach of fiduciary duty and a judgment awarding the legatees $310,848.97 was rendered on May 15, 2009.1 That judgment was affirmed by this court and is now final.2

On June 5, 2009, less than a month after the money judgment against him, Mr. Witty established a trust with his daughter, Ms. Gibbs, a resident of Michigan. Ms. Gibbs, as trustee, had broad authority under the Michigan trust agreement, including the ability to move assets in and out of the trust at her discretion. While the appeal of the judgment was pending, Mr. Witty transferred his only Louisiana asset, a $100,000.00 legacy from the succession, of his cousin, Murray LeBeau, into the trust.

Also, ón June 5,-2009, a death tragically occuived on Ms. Gibbs’ property in Michigan during her son’s graduation party at their home. As a result, Ms. Gibbs was criminally charged with' tampering with evidence and'was also civilly sued for wrongful death in Michigan. Mr. Elliott learned of these actions and contacted the Michigan attorney suing Ms. Gibbs in the wrongful death suit.' Mr. Elliott sent' the Michigan attorney a copy of the trust and an affidavit stating in |spart that the trust agreement between Mr. Witty and Ms.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.