Texas Supreme Court March 8, 2013, No. 11-0261 (Combs v. Roark Amusement & Vending, L.P.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-03-2013

Justice WILLETT

delivered the opinion of the Court.

Roark Amusement & Vending, L.P. brought this tax-refund suit against the Comptroller of Public Accounts, seeking to recoup sales taxes it paid on “plush toy” prizes used to stock its coin-operated amusement machines. The court of appeals held the toys were exempt from sales tax under the Tax Code’s sale-for-resale exemption. We agree and affirm the court of appeals’ judgment.

I. Factual and Procedural Background

The facts are undisputed, having been established below in a stipulation of facts or in uncontested affidavits. Roark owns and leases coin-operated amusement crane machines that are found in supermarkets, restaurants, and shopping malls throughout Texas. Customers aim to win plush toys by using a joystick to maneuver a mechanical claw to grab the toys and drop them into a prize chute. Successful customers keep the prizes, and eventually all the toys become property of customers in this manner (except for those lost, stolen, or damaged).

Roark sought a refund of the sales taxes it paid on the toys it purchased to stock its machines for the period October 1, 2000 through February 29, 2004.1 It argued that the toys were exempt under the sale-for-resale exemption discussed below. The Comptroller disputed that the exemption applied.

The trial court granted the Comptroller’s motion for summary judgment and denied Roark’s refund request. The court of appeals reversed, concluding the toys were exempt, and remanded the case to the trial court for a determination of the refund amount due Roark.2 We granted the Comptroller’s petition for review.

II. Discussion

Our decision turns on the interplay of various Tax Code provisions found in chapter 151.

• The Sales Tax Generally: Section 151.051(a) imposes a sales tax “on each sale of a taxable item in this state.” “ ‘Taxable item’ means tangible personal property and taxable services.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.