New York Court of Claims March 6, 2013, Claim No. 115999 (Marabello v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-03-2013

OPINION OF THE COURT

W. Brooks DeBow, J.

This claim alleges that claimant1 is a young adult with disabilities who, on October 18, 2008 and prior thereto, was a resident of a group home in Brooklyn, New York that was owned and operated by the defendant. The claim alleges that claimant sustained injuries as a result of an assault by defendant’s employees, as well as various acts of negligence. This motion by claimants seeks an order compelling defendant to produce certain documents that have been withheld by defendant, and which defendant contends are “quality assurance” materials that are privileged pursuant to Education Law § 6527 and Mental Hygiene Law § 29.29 (see Bauer affirmation, exhibit A [privilege log]). Claimants contend that the New York State statutory privilege against disclosure of quality assurance documents as set forth in Education Law § 6527 and Mental Hygiene Law § 29.29 is superseded and preempted by certain provisions of the Federal Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and its enabling regulations. Defendant opposes the motion.

Claimants seek production of 125 pages of documents from a “Quality Assurance” file that defendant has withheld on the ground that they are privileged pursuant to Education Law § 6527 and Mental Hygiene Law § 29.29, and which are described in defendant’s privilege log (see Bauer affirmation, exhibit A; Curtis affirmation in opposition, exhibit B). With the exception of one document described as a “Notifications Sheet,” all of the documents recited in the privilege log refer to an “incident,” “investigation,” or “interview.” Claimants have submitted an affirmation of Adam N. Raff, M.D.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.