New York Supreme Court October 29, 2013 (Saska v. Metropolitan Museum of Art)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-10-2013

OPINION OF THE COURT

Shirley Werner Kornreich, J.

The instant actions concern the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s “pay what you wish” admissions policy. At the heart of these cases is whether this policy and the manner in which it is enforced runs afoul of General Business Law § 349, a nineteenth-century statute which provided funding to the Museum, and the lease between the Museum and the City of New York, executed in 1878. The Museum now moves to dismiss plaintiffs’ causes of action based on the statute and the lease. The Museum’s motion is granted for the reasons that follow.

I. Procedural History

On November 14, 2012, plaintiffs Theodore Grünewald and Patricia Nicholson commenced an action against the Museum and its directors, seeking injunctive relief. Their complaint (the Grünewald complaint) states six causes of action: (1) breach of the lease (asserted as purported third-party beneficiaries) by failing to provide free admission; (2) violation of chapter 476 of the Laws of 1893 (the 1893 act) by charging admission; (3) violation of General Business Law § 349 regarding admission costs; (4) misrepresentation regarding admission costs; (5) injunctive *550relief compelling the Museum to “restore the Central Park entrance”; and (6) injunctive relief compelling the Museum to comply with environmental regulations necessary so that construction of the Central Park entrance can begin. The Grünewald complaint does not seek monetary damages. Defendants filed an answer to the Grünewald complaint on March 14, 2013.

Meantime, on March 5, 2013, plaintiffs Filip Saska and Tomá Nadrchal, residents of the Czech Republic, and plaintiff Stephen Michelman, a New York resident, commenced a putative class action against the Museum based on allegations that are virtually identical to those alleged in the Grünewald complaint concerning admission costs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.