Court of Appeals of Oregon May 15, 2013, 060910333; A148407 (Marton v. Ater Construction Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2013

SCHUMAN, P. J.

This case arises out of construction defects in plaintiffs’ home. Plaintiffs sued Ater Construction Company, LLC (Ater), the builder of the home. Ater, in turn, filed a third-party complaint against a number of its subcontractors and suppliers, including Marvin Windows, Inc. (Marvin), who manufactured the windows used on the home, and Medallion Industries, Inc. (Medallion), the windows distributor. Ater and plaintiffs eventually elected to enter into what is known as a Mary Carter agreement, whereby Ater would remain in the litigation as a defendant but its ultimate liability to plaintiffs would be capped at $100,000. Subsequently, Marvin and Medallion moved for summary judgment on Ater’s third-party claims, arguing that, because the Mary Carter agreement extinguished only Ater’s liability — and not Marvin’s or Medallion’s liability — Ater’s claims for contribution and indemnity failed as a matter of law. Marvin and Medallion also argued that Ater’s negligence claim against them was barred by the economic loss doctrine. The trial court agreed with Marvin’s and Medallion’s arguments and granted summary judgment. Ater now appeals, and we affirm the judgment of the trial court.

The facts underlying the trial court’s summary judgment ruling relate, for the most part, to the procedural history of the case. In 1998, plaintiffs purchased a home that was constructed by Ater. In April 2006, plaintiffs discovered water intrusion and related property damage, which they attributed to construction defects in the home. A few months after discovering those defects, plaintiffs filed an action against Ater for breach of contract and negligence. Shortly thereafter, in December 2006, Ater filed a third-party complaint against a number of the subcontractors and suppliers including Marvin and Medallion, alleging that those parties were at fault and therefore liable to Ater for any damages awarded to plaintiffs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.