Court of Appeals of Oregon June 26, 2013, 110469; A149566 (State ex rel. Department of Transportation v. Singh)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-06-2013

DUNCAN, J.

In this condemnation case, plaintiff, the Oregon Department of Transportation, appeals a judgment of the trial court dismissing its condemnation action against defendant.1 On defendant’s motion for summary judgment, the trial court concluded that plaintiffs prelitigation offer, required by ORS 35.346(1), to acquire an easement on part of defendant’s property and to compensate him for the loss of rights of access to public roads was insufficiently definite because it did not specify the road access that defendant’s parcel would have after the acquisition. The court dismissed the action without prejudice, and plaintiff appeals.2 We affirm.

The relevant facts are undisputed. Highway 34 runs west and east and Peoria Road runs north and south, and they intersect in Linn County. Defendant owns the parcel of land at the southeast corner of that intersection, and he operates a convenience store on the site. Defendant owns two specific rights of access from the north side of his property to Highway 34, and he has a common-law right of access from the west side of his property to Peoria Road. Thus, defendant has three rights of access from his property to public roads.

As part of a road improvement project at the intersection, plaintiff sought to eliminate defendant’s two specific rights of access to Highway 34. It also sought to acquire a permanent easement over property on the west side of defendant’s parcel, which would eliminate defendant’s common-law right of access to Peoria Road. In order to preserve access to defendant’s property, plaintiff planned to build a new road from Peoria Road to defendant’s property. The new road would begin two parcels south of defendant’s parcel. In order to build the new road, plaintiff planned to acquire easements over the two parcels south of defendant’s parcel.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.