West Virginia Supreme Court May 21, 2013, 11-1694 (In Re: Name Change of Jenna A. J.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-2013

No. 11-1694 - In re: Name Change of Jenna A.J.

FILED

May 21, 2013

RORY L. PERRY II, CLERK

SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS

OF WEST VIRGINIA

Workman, Justice, Dissenting:

I dissent both from the Court’s judgment in this case and from most of the majority’s

reasoning. The decision of the circuit court was well within its discretion and I see no

principled basis on which to overturn it; this Court has, in effect, re-weighed the evidence,

utilizing certain hard-and-fast rules, tests and presumptions we have previously mandated in

our seminal name change cases, In re Harris, 160 W. Va. 422, 236 S.E.2d 426 (1977), and

Lufft v. Lufft, 188 W. Va. 339, 424 S.E.2d 266 (1992).1 In my view, with respect to those

cases, this Court’s opinion in Harris has long since outlived its judge-made sociological

underpinnings, and our opinion in Lufft is a textbook example of the adage that hard cases

make bad law. In short, our precedents are outmoded and completely unmoored from what

should be the focus in these cases: the best interests of the child, taking into account the

1

Although not the basis for this dissenting opinion, I take issue with the majority’s

conclusion that for purposes of this Court’s analysis in a name change case, a petition

seeking to hyphenate a child’s surname is no different from a petition to change the child’s

surname entirely. In the former circumstance, presented in both Harris and Lufft, one parent

is confronted with the elimination of his or her surname altogether; in the latter, the parent’s

surname is sought to be joined with that of the other parent. E.g., Andrews v. Andrews, 454

N.W.2d 488, 491 (Neb. 1990) (“Consequently, the proposed and requested change in the

children’s surname . . . reflects both maternal and paternal surnames.”). I believe that where

hyphenation, rather than elimination, of a name is sought, this is one of many factors to be

considered in deciding whether a name change petition should be granted. See text infra.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.