District Court, M.D. Tennessee January 31, 2013, No. 3:10-01033 (Protective Industries, Inc. v. Ratermann Manufacturing, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 31-01-2013
MEMORANDUM ON CLAIM CONSTRUCTION
KEVIN H. SHARP, District Judge.
There are numerous pending motions in this patent infringement case in which Plaintiff Protective Industries Inc., d.b.a. Caplugs, (“Plaintiff’ or “Caplugs”) claims that Defendants Ratermann Manufacturing, Inc. (“RMI”), George Ratermann (“Ratermann”), Progressive Plastics, Inc. (“Progressive”) and Henry Buermann (“Buermann”) (collectively “Defendants”) have infringed and continue to infringe on United States Patent No. 7,681,587 (“the '587 patent”). Those motions — ranging from summary judgment motions to motions in limine — have been fully briefed by the parties.
I. BACKGROUND
This Court has previously addressed the patent at issue in a 21-page claim construction opinion, (Docket No. 126; Protective Indus. Inc. v. Ratermann Manuf., 2012 WL 1598042 (M.D.Tenn. May 7, 2012)), basic familiarity with which is assumed. Nevertheless, and to provide context to the motions, the Court provides the following general background. This back*871ground will be expanded upon where necessary for purposes of a specific motion.
Invented by Frederick Zeyfang (“Zeyfang”), the '587 patent is a Gas Bottle Valve Stem Protective Sleeve for use as a protective device on the valve stem of a compressed gas cylinder and, in particular, the three-holed CGA-870 valve used on medical oxygen gas cylinders. Because oxygen bottles are shipped and stored after filling, it is desirable that the valve, and particularly the orifice through which the oxygen passes, be protected. It is also desirable that any such protective device be easy to install and easy to remove because oxygen cylinders are filled in large quantities in gas filling plants, and the end users are often elderly or infirm.
Plaintiffs protective sleeve is a four-sided plastic sleeve which slides over the top of the valve stem and is configured to fit snugly around the valve.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit