District Court, N.D. Oklahoma May 23, 2013, Case No. 10-CV-536-JED-FHM (Ingle ex rel. Estate of Ingle v. Metropolitan Life Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-05-2013
OPINION AND ORDER
JOHN E. DOWDELL, District Judge.
Plaintiff filed this action in state court as Administrator of the Estate of Clifton Chad Ingle, deceased, seeking to recover accidental death benefits pursuant to a policy Ingle had with defendant, Metropolitan Life Insurance Company (“Metlife”). Metlife removed the action to this Court under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, 29 U.S.C. § 2202 et seq. (“ERISA”). The parties disagree about two issues: which standard of review applies to this Court’s review of Met-life’s decision to deny benefits and whether Mr. Ingle’s death falls under either of two exclusions found in the relevant policy.
I. Facts
Clifton Ingle, age 26, died as a result of eating food tainted by Escherichia Coli (“E.eoli”) at the Country Cottage restaurant in Locust Grove, Oklahoma. On August 21, 2008, Mr. Ingle was admitted to Integris Mayes County Medical Center in nearby Pryor, Oklahoma, after becoming physically ill with abdominal cramps, nausea, and bloody diarrhea. (Rec. 111). The next day, he was transferred to Saint Francis Hospital in Tulsa, where he was found to have sepsis with subsequent shock, seizures, hypotension, and pulmonary, renal, and liver failure resulting from the E. coli. (Rec. 109). Ingle’s condition worsened on August 23, when he suffered several grand mal seizures and required a series of cardiopulmonary resuscitations. (Rec. 109).
On August 24, 2008, Mr. Ingle died. His Certificate of Death indicates that the cause of death was hemorrhagic colitis and that his death was attributable to “natural causes.” (Rec. 64). The Chief Medical Examiner later explained, from a medical standpoint, that infectious disease is considered a natural cause of death and that the Examiner’s determination was not a legal opinion. (Rec. 98). The record reveals that the E. coli outbreak which caused Mr. Ingle’s death rendered 341 people ill, of which 70 required hospitalization. (Rec. 115).
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit