Court of Appeals of North Carolina March 5, 2013, No. COA12-1093 (Carle v. Wyrick, Robbins, Yates & Ponton, LLP)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-03-2013
STROUD, Judge.
Scott Carle and John Simmons (“plaintiffs”) filed a complaint against the law firm of Wyrick, Robbins, Yates, and Ponton, LLP, and attorney Madison Bullard, Jr. (“defendants”) on 25 January 2010 alleging professional negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, negligent or intentional misrepresentation, constructive fraud, and breach of contract. Plaintiffs appeal from an order entered 28 June 2012 in Superior Court, Wake County, granting defendants’ motion for summary judgment.
I. Background
Plaintiffs were joint owners of East Coast Drilling and Blasting, Inc. (“East Coast”). In 2004, they decided to create an employee stock ownership trust (“ESOP Trust”) and to “monetize” their stock in East Coast. To do so, they enlisted the help of a variety of advisors, including a CPA and a separate financial adviser to coordinate the transaction. Plaintiffs retained defendants to represent their personal interests in the transaction. Other firms were retained to represent plaintiffs’ corporation and the ESOP trustee. On the advice of defendants, plaintiffs *657later retained the firm of Holland and Knight to provide an opinion letter on the tax implications of the transaction.
The transaction was supposed to be structured so that plaintiffs would be able to “monetize” their corporate stock while avoiding the capital gains taxes normally associated with doing so. The transaction consisted of three parts: (1) the sale and transfer of the East Coast stock to the ESOP trust, (2) a one-day loan of $8,000,000 to East Coast to finance the transfer, and (3) the monetization of the sale price to defer the taxes payable on the sale through the purchase of qualified replacement securities (“QRS”).
Plaintiff Carle sold 9,000 shares of his East Coast stock to the ESOP Trust in exchange for $9,022,410, consisting of $1,822,410 in cash and a promissory note worth $7,200,000 from East Coast.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit