Washington Supreme Court March 14, 2013, 86412-8 (In re Estate of Haviland)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-03-2013

This opinfori-was filed for record

at $ \oo a"""' on N\acc~r-. l Ll, un ~

~~·

~r ~uprema Court Clerk

y

Ronald R. CarpentM-

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WASHINGTON

In the Matter of the Estate of )

) No. 86412-8

JAMES W. HAVILAND, )

) EnBanc

Deceased. )

) Filed -MAR 14 2013

MADSEN, C.J.-During the pendency of a will contest involving Dr. James

Haviland's estate, the legislature amended the slayer statutes to disinherit those who

financially abuse vulnerable adults. In light of the amendments, the administrator of the

Haviland estate requested the trial court to determine whether Mary Haviland should be

disinherited based on her conduct as found by the trial court. The trial court determined

that the abuser statutes could not be applied to deny Ms. Haviland benefits from the

Haviland estate because the statutes are triggered by financial abuse, which would require

improper retroactive application of the statutes. The Court of Appeals reversed and

remanded for further proceedings, holding that the petition filed during probate to

adjudicate whether an individual is an abuser is the triggering event for application of the

statutes and that the statutes acted prospectively as applied to this estate. We affirm the

No. 86412-8

Court of Appeals and hold that the abuser statutes act prospectively and that the filing of

the abuser petition during probate triggers the statutes.

FACTS

Dr. James Haviland was a medical doctor practicing in the Seattle area. For

several decades, he was married to Marion Haviland, with whom he had four children.

She died in 1993 and much of their estate was put into a living trust for the benefit of Dr.

Haviland and his children and grandchildren upon his death. Three years later, Dr.

Haviland, then 85, met 35-year-old Mary Haviland (then Mary Burden) who worked at

Providence Hospital where he was a patient. Following Dr. Haviland's discharge, he and

Ms.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.