District Court, D. Guam April 14, 2014, 1:93-cv-00041 (United States v. Urunao Beach Corp.)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-04-2014

1

2

3

4 IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

5 TERRITORY OF GUAM

6

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ) CIVIL CASE NO. 93-00041

7 )

Plaintiff, )

8 )

vs. ) MEMORANDUM DECISION

9 ) ) AND ORDER DENYING MOTION

10 ANTONIO ARTERO SABLAN, ) TO REOPEN CASE

Individually and as Chairman of the Board )

11 and President of Urunao Beach Corp dba )

JUNGLE TOURS, and URUNAO BEACH )

12 CORP., )

)

13 Defendants. )

14

I. INTRODUCTION

15

16 Before the court is a motion by Melvia Artero Cafky and Anthony M. Artero (collectively

17 “Movants”) to reopen this case. (Motion to Reopen Case (“Motion”), filed July 16, 2013, ECF No.

18

44.) Movants are not parties to the litigation, but they claim to be intended third-party beneficiaries

19

of a consent decree entered into by the parties in 1994, and as such to have standing to ask the

20

court to clarify the decree’s terms. Plaintiff United States opposes the Motion. Defendants Antonio

21

22 Artero Sablan (“Sablan”) and Urunao Beach Corporation (“Urunao Beach”) have not filed

23 responsive briefs or taken a position on the Motion. The matter came on for a hearing on March

24

20, 2014. Having carefully considered the oral and written arguments of counsel, and having

25

reviewed the briefs, affidavits, and exhibits submitted by Movants and Plaintiff, the court denies

26

27 the Motion to Reopen Case, for the reasons set forth herein.

28

II. BACKGROUND

1

a. The 1994 Consent Decree

2

3 In 1993, the United States sued Defendants Sablan and Urunao Beach for trespass, alleging

4 that Defendants had damaged federal woodlands by unlawfully cutting a roadway through Lot

5

10081-2 in the Guam National Wildlife Refuge (“Refuge”) to Defendants’ property in Lot 10080

6

and by driving tour buses over it, further damaging the ecosystem. (See Complaint, ECF 1.)

7

8 Defendants asserted a right of easement by necessity. (See Consent Decree ¶ 7.) A previous

9 judgment in a separate case, United States v. 602,321 Square Meters of Land, Civil Case No. 29-

10

62 (D.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.