Nebraska Supreme Court February 7, 2014, S-11-486 (State v. Ramirez)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-02-2014

Nebraska Advance Sheets

356 287 NEBRASKA REPORTS

without merit under either alternative formulation, his coun-

sel was not ineffective in not asserting it at sentencing or on

direct appeal.

CONCLUSION

To summarize, in my view, the rule announced in Miller is

procedural and does not apply to Mantich on collateral review.

I would find that Graham has no application to Mantich’s

sentence of life imprisonment for first degree felony murder,

a homicide, and that Mantich’s alternative claim that his sen-

tence was grossly disproportionate to his crime is procedurally

barred. Because these claims are without merit, Mantich’s trial

and appellate counsel was not ineffective in failing to assert

them. And because the files and records conclusively show that

Mantich’s motion for postconviction relief is without merit, the

district court did not err in denying the requested relief without

conducting an evidentiary hearing. I would affirm the decision

of the district court.

Heavican, C.J., joins in this dissent.

State of Nebraska, appellee, v.

Eric A. Ramirez, appellant.

___ N.W.2d ___

Filed February 7, 2014. No. S-11-486.

1. Rules of Evidence. In proceedings where the Nebraska Evidence Rules apply, the

admissibility of evidence is controlled by the Nebraska Evidence Rules; judicial

discretion is involved only when the rules make such discretion a factor in deter-

mining admissibility.

2. Rules of Evidence: Appeal and Error. Where the Nebraska Evidence Rules

commit the evidentiary question at issue to the discretion of the trial court, an

appellate court reviews the admissibility of evidence for an abuse of discretion.

3. Judgments: Words and Phrases. An abuse of discretion occurs when a trial

court’s decision is based upon reasons that are untenable or unreasonable or if its

action is clearly against justice or conscience, reason, and evidence.

4. Trial: Evidence: Appeal and Error.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.