Supreme Court of Virginia January 10, 2014, 121984 (Simpson v. Roberts)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-01-2014

PRESENT: All the Justices

MARISSA R. SIMPSON, AN INFANT,

WHO SUES BY HER FATHER AND

NEXT FRIEND

OPINION BY

v. Record No. 121984 JUSTICE DONALD W. LEMONS

JANUARY 10, 2014

DAVID ROBERTS, ET AL.

FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE CITY OF ROANOKE

William D. Broadhurst, Judge

In this appeal we consider whether the Circuit Court of the

City of Roanoke ("trial court") erred when it held that Marissa

R. Simpson ("Simpson") was a patient of Dr. David Roberts ("Dr.

Roberts") and that her claim arose under Virginia's Medical

Malpractice Act, Code §§ 8.01-581.1 et seq. ("Act"), and was

subject to the Act's statutory cap on damages, Code § 8.01-

581.15.

I. Facts and Proceedings Below

Simpson filed a motion for judgment in 2003, by her father

and next friend, Christopher Simpson, against Dr. Roberts, Dr.

J. Bradley Terry, and Southwest Virginia Physicians for Women,

Inc. (collectively referred to as the "defendants"). 1 Simpson

alleged that as a result of the defendants' negligence, she was

born with serious and permanent injuries. In her motion for

judgment, Simpson asserted that her claims were common law

1

Simpson also sued Dr. Leslie E. Badillo and Carilion Healthcare

Corporation; however, those parties are not involved in this

appeal.

claims for medical malpractice because the treatment in question

was not covered under the Act. Simpson demanded $10 million in

damages.

The defendants filed a demurrer, arguing that the motion

for judgment failed to state a cause of action for common law

medical malpractice, failed to state why it was not covered by

the Act, and that the ad damnum exceeded the statutory cap under

the Act. A hearing on the demurrer was held on August 11, 2005,

where Simpson clarified that she was only alleging her claim

against Dr. Roberts was not covered by the cap. Simpson argued

that at the time Dr. Roberts breached the standard of care, she

was not a "natural person" because she had not yet been born,

and therefore was not a "patient" as defined by the Act.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.