Nebraska Supreme Court July 18, 2014, S-13-616 (J.M. v. Hobbs)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-07-2014

Nebraska Advance Sheets

546 288 NEBRASKA REPORTS

J.M., as Guardian and Conservator for his minor child,

C.M., appellant and cross-appellee, v. Billy L.

Hobbs, appellee and cross-appellant.

___ N.W.2d ___

Filed July 18, 2014. No. S-13-616.

1. Constitutional Law: Statutes: Appeal and Error. The constitutionality of

a statute presents a question of law, which an appellate court independently

reviews.

2. Constitutional Law: Statutes: Presumptions. A court presumes that statutes are

constitutional and will not strike down a statute unless its unconstitutionality is

clearly established.

3. Special Legislation. A legislative act constitutes special legislation if (1) it cre-

ates an arbitrary and unreasonable method of classification or (2) it creates a

permanently closed class.

4. ____. A special legislation analysis focuses on a legislative body’s purpose in

creating a challenged class and asks if there is a substantial difference of circum-

stances to suggest the expediency of diverse legislation. The prohibition aims to

prevent legislation that arbitrarily benefits a special class.

5. Constitutional Law: Statutes: Special Legislation. When the Legislature con-

fers privileges on a class arbitrarily selected from many who are standing in the

same relation to the privileges, without reasonable distinction or substantial dif-

ference, then the statute in question has resulted in the kind of improper discrimi-

nation prohibited by the Nebraska Constitution.

6. Special Legislation: Public Policy. To be valid, a legislative classification must

rest upon some reason of public policy, some substantial difference in circum-

stances, which would naturally suggest the justice or expediency of diverse legis-

lation regarding the objects to be classified.

7. Constitutional Law: Special Legislation. Legislative classifications must be

real and not illusive; they cannot be based on distinctions without a substantial

difference.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.