Supreme Court of Missouri July 29, 2014, SC93851 (State of Missouri v. Sylvester Porter)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-07-2014

SUPREME COURT OF MISSOURI

en banc

State of Missouri, )

)

Respondent, )

)

vs. ) No. SC93851

)

Sylvester Porter, )

)

Appellant. )

APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE CITY OF ST. LOUIS

The Honorable Timothy J. Wilson, Judge

Opinion issued July 29, 2014

Sylvester Porter appeals a judgment convicting him of two counts of statutory

sodomy in the first degree. Porter argues that the trial court erred in denying his motion

for judgment of acquittal because the victim’s testimony was contradictory and lacked

corroboration. Porter’s argument is based on the “corroboration rule” and the

“destructive contradictions” doctrine. 1 This Court abolishes both the corroboration rule

and destructive contradictions doctrine because, among other reasons, both require

appellate courts to act as the finder of fact. Review of the record according to the

1

As explained in more detail below, the corroboration rule provides that an appellate

court is to disregard a sex crime victim’s testimony if it is contradictory and

uncorroborated. The destructive contradictions doctrine permits an appellate court to

disregard testimony relevant to an element of the crime if the court determines that the

testimony is inherently incredible.

applicable standard of review demonstrates there was sufficient evidence to support the

jury’s finding that Porter committed statutory sodomy.

Porter also contends that the trial court erred in allowing the jury to have

unrestricted access to the videotaped forensic interview of the victim during its

deliberations. This point is without merit because Porter did not object or develop a

factual record showing the extent of the jury’s review of the video.

The judgment is affirmed.

Facts

Porter managed a rooming house where A.L. rented a room for herself and her

three-year-old daughter, K.W. Porter, also known as “J-Money,” had a room at the

boarding house.

One weekend, K.W.’s grandmother took care of K.W. while A.L. was away.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.