Supreme Court of Georgia March 10, 2014, S13A1395, S13A1396 (Bibb County v. Monroe County)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-03-2014
294 Ga. 730
FINAL COPY
S13A1395. BIBB COUNTY v. MONROE COUNTY et al.
S13A1396. KEMP v. MONROE COUNTY.
HUNSTEIN, Justice.
These appeals involve a long-running boundary line dispute between
Monroe County and Bibb County, which has culminated in a superior court
order directing Secretary of State Brian Kemp to accept a line identified by a
State-appointed land surveyor as the true boundary line separating the two
counties. This Court granted the applications for discretionary appeal filed
separately by Bibb County and Secretary Kemp to address the propriety of the
relief granted below. We now hold that, while mandamus may lie to require the
Secretary of State to comply with his statutory obligations with regard to county
boundary line disputes, see OCGA § 36-3-20 et seq., the superior court lacked
the authority to require Secretary Kemp to accept a particular line as the true
boundary line. Specifically, while mandamus is authorized to compel the
Secretary to consider the relevant law and evidence, to determine the true
boundary line between the counties, and to record the survey and plat reflecting
that boundary line, mandamus is not authorized to dictate where the boundary
line is to be located. Accordingly, we reverse and remand for further
proceedings.
In 2005, Governor Sonny Perdue appointed land surveyor Terry
Scarborough to identify the boundary between the counties, pursuant to a
statutory process for settling boundary disputes first established in the 1880s.
See OCGA § 36-3-20 et seq.; Ga. L. 1887, pp. 106-107. In April 2008, after
receiving formal authorization to proceed from the Secretary of State (“the
Secretary”), Scarborough conducted his survey work and submitted his final
survey and plat to the Secretary on March 27, 2009, delineating what he
concluded was the true boundary line separating Monroe County and Bibb
County.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit